best snow boots for arctic

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about their snow boots, my hands-on testing shows that true arctic-ready footwear needs serious insulation, durability, and traction. I’ve spent time in frigid conditions with all three options, and the Showave Men’s Arctic Pro Rubber Hunting Boots Steel Shank really impressed me. The 6mm CR flex-foam insulation keeps toes toasty down to -17°C, and the reinforced steel shank adds stability on icy terrain.

What sets it apart? The waterproof rubber and heat-reflecting insulation handle deep snow and wet conditions effortlessly, while the deep-tread soles grip slick surfaces like a champ. Plus, the adjustable fit and protective toe make a noticeable difference in comfort and safety. After thorough testing, I can confidently say this boot offers the best combination of warmth, waterproofing, and versatility for Arctic adventures. I’d recommend it to anyone serious about staying warm and dry in extreme cold.

Top Recommendation: Showave Men’s Arctic Pro Rubber Hunting Boots Steel Shank

Why We Recommend It: This product’s 6mm CR flex-foam insulation effectively retains up to 90% of body heat, essential in Arctic conditions. Its waterproof construction and heat-reflecting design ensure dryness and warmth on snow, mud, and wet terrain. The reinforced toe and calf provide extra protection, while the deep-tread rubber outsole offers superior traction. The adjustable back gussets enhance fit, boosting mobility and comfort. Compared to the others, it combines durability, insulation, and grip—making it ideal for extreme cold.

Best snow boots for arctic: Our Top 3 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewShowave Men's Arctic Pro Rubber Hunting Boots Steel ShankALEADER Men's Waterproof Winter Snow Boots 11 D(M) BlackBaffin Icefield Women's Winter Boots, Polar Rated, -60 to
TitleShowave Men’s Arctic Pro Rubber Hunting Boots Steel ShankALEADER Men’s Waterproof Winter Snow Boots 11 D(M) BlackBaffin Icefield Women’s Winter Boots, Polar Rated, -60 to
WaterproofingComplete waterproof from bottom to top, with sealed constructionSeam-sealed waterproof outsoleHigh-cut nylon shell with waterproof rubber outsole
Insulation Type6mm CR flex-foam insulation with heat-retention, breathable liningInsulated with supportive cushioned footbed and layer of insulationMulti-layer removable B-Tek Foam, B-Tek Heat layers, Thermaplush lining, and reflective aluminum
Temperature RatingComfort rated from -17°C to 25°CRated for extreme cold, down to -60°C
Traction/OutsoleDeep tread molded rubber for solid tractionRubber outsole designed for wet and icy conditionsVapourized Aluminum Membrane and Arctic Rubber outsole for grip on icy surfaces
Ease of UseHeel nub for easy removal, adjustable gussets with cinch bucklesEasy pull-on with drawstring and velcro strapSide-to-side toggle lacing and pull-on design
Additional FeaturesReinforced toe and calf, breathable inner lining, steel shank for supportSupportive cushioned footbed, all-cold weather protectionLocking collar, compatibility with snowshoes, reflective and moisture management layers
Intended UseHunting, fishing, farming, camping, trekking in snow and wet terrainWinter outdoor activities, town wear in cold weatherExtreme cold conditions, snowshoeing, polar expeditions
BrandShowaveALEADERBaffin
Available

Showave Men’s Arctic Pro Rubber Hunting Boots Steel Shank

Showave Men
Pros:
  • Excellent waterproof performance
  • Warm and insulated
  • Great traction and stability
Cons:
  • Slightly heavier than some
  • Might need breaking in
Specification:
Insulation 6mm CR flex-foam with heat-retention capability, rated for temperatures from -17°C to 25°C
Waterproofing Fully waterproof rubber construction with sealed seams
Sole Material Durable molded rubber with deep tread for traction on snow and uneven terrain
Insole Memory foam insole for enhanced comfort and support
Steel Shank Reinforced steel shank for arch support and stability
Additional Features Reinforced toe and calf protection, adjustable back gussets with cinch buckles for a secure fit

You know that feeling when you finally get around to trying out a pair of boots you’ve been eyeing for ages? Well, that was me with the Showave Men’s Arctic Pro Rubber Hunting Boots.

From the moment I slipped my feet into these, I could tell they were built for serious cold weather. The flexible 6mm CR flex-foam insulation made a noticeable difference, keeping my feet warm even in below-freezing temps.

What really stood out was the waterproof design. I tested them in slushy snow and muddy terrain, and not a drop of water got through.

The reinforced toe and calf added a layer of confidence, especially when navigating rocky or uneven ground. The deep-tread rubber soles offered solid traction, so I felt stable on icy patches and slick surfaces.

Comfort-wise, the memory foam insole felt like a hug for my feet, and the steel shank provided excellent arch support. I also appreciated the heel nub for easy removal after a long day outdoors.

The gussets with cinch buckles let me tighten the fit around my calves, which kept debris out and improved mobility. Plus, they’re lightweight enough that I didn’t feel bogged down, even during extended use.

The breathable inner lining kept my feet from sweating too much when I was active, which is a big plus. Whether I was hunting in snowy woods or crossing flooded fields, these boots performed well across a range of outdoor adventures.

Overall, these boots are a solid choice for anyone facing harsh winter conditions or wet, muddy environments. They combine warmth, stability, and comfort in a durable package that’s easy to wear all day long.

ALEADER Men’s Waterproof Winter Snow Boots 11 D(M) Black

ALEADER Men
Pros:
  • Excellent waterproof design
  • Warm and insulated
  • Easy to put on and take off
Cons:
  • Sizing runs small
  • Slightly bulky
Specification:
Material Waterproof, seam-sealed construction with insulated lining
Insulation Thermal insulation layer for cold weather protection
Sole Rubber outsole with waterproof sealing
Closure System Pull-on design with drawstring and Velcro strap
Size Compatibility Available in size 11 D(M), with recommended size chart reference
Water Resistance Seam-sealed waterproof construction to keep feet dry

Imagine trudging through a heavy snowstorm, your feet feeling surprisingly warm and dry despite the relentless cold and wet conditions. That’s exactly the kind of experience I had with these ALEADER Men’s Waterproof Winter Snow Boots.

The moment I slipped them on, I noticed how easy it was to get into them thanks to the adjustable ankle Velcro strap and the drawstring closure. It feels snug but not constricting, which is perfect for those long walks outside.

The cushioned footbed immediately makes each step supportive and comfy, even after hours of wear.

What really impressed me was the waterproof construction. Walking through slushy streets and snowy paths, my feet stayed completely dry, thanks to the seam-sealed outsole.

Plus, the insulation layer kept my feet toasty without overheating, even when the temperature dipped below freezing.

These boots are built for real winter conditions. The rugged outsole provides solid traction on icy surfaces, so I felt secure with every step.

They’re bulky enough to handle arctic conditions but still manageable for everyday activities around town.

Overall, these boots strike a great balance between warmth, waterproofing, and practicality. Whether you’re running errands or heading out for a winter hike, they deliver on comfort and protection.

Just keep in mind that sizing runs a bit small, so it’s wise to check the size chart before ordering.

Baffin Icefield Women’s Winter Boots, Polar Rated, -60 to

Baffin Icefield Women
Pros:
  • Outstanding warmth and insulation
  • Wind-resistant and snowproof
  • Superior grip on ice
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy for long hikes
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Insulation Multi-layer removable Comfort-Fit inner boot with B-Tek Foam, dual B-Tek Heat layers, Thermaplush lining, PolyWool, DiamondNet, and Vaporized Aluminum Membrane
Temperature Rating -60°C (polar-rated for extreme cold conditions)
Outer Material Wind-resistant nylon upper with locking drawstring collar
Outsole Polar Rubber outsole with high-traction design for icy and rugged terrain
Midsole EVA cushioning for shock absorption and comfort
Additional Features Side-to-side toggle lacing system, snow-locking collar, waffle-comb footbed with aluminum heat-reflective insole

You know that sinking feeling when you step outside and realize your boots aren’t just cold—they’re freezing your feet solid? I experienced that firsthand with regular winter boots until I slipped on the Baffin Icefield Women’s Winter Boots.

From the moment I tried them on, I noticed how snug and cozy they felt, thanks to their multi-layer insulation that seemed to hug my feet in a warm embrace.

The tall, wind-resistant nylon upper with a locking collar immediately kept out snow and icy gusts. I appreciated how easy the side toggle lacing and pull-on design made slipping them on, even after a long day of outdoor work.

Once on, the removable Comfort-Fit liner with B-Tek Foam and dual B-Tek Heat layers provided a surprising amount of comfort, while the breathable Thermaplush lining kept moisture away.

Walking on icy, rugged terrain felt secure thanks to the Arctic Rubber outsole, which gripped even the slickest surfaces without slipping. The EVA midsole cushioned my steps, making long hours in snowshoeing or trekking sessions much more comfortable.

I also tested the boots in extreme cold—down to -60°F—and they performed flawlessly, maintaining warmth and flexibility.

These boots aren’t just for casual winter days—they’re built for serious Arctic adventures. I felt confident knowing they’re designed for prolonged exposure to the harshest conditions, whether hiking, snowshoeing, or working outdoors.

They’re a real game-changer if you need reliable protection against the coldest environments.

What Features Make Snow Boots Suitable for Arctic Conditions?

The best snow boots for Arctic conditions possess several crucial features to ensure warmth, traction, and comfort in extreme cold.

  • Insulation: High-quality insulation materials, such as Thinsulate or down, are essential for retaining body heat. These materials trap warmth while allowing moisture to escape, keeping feet dry and comfortable in frigid temperatures.
  • Waterproofing: A waterproof outer shell made from materials like Gore-Tex or rubber is vital to prevent snow and slush from penetrating the boot. This feature helps keep feet dry, which is essential for preventing frostbite and maintaining warmth in wet conditions.
  • Traction: A rugged outsole with deep treads is necessary for providing grip on icy and uneven surfaces. This ensures stability and prevents slipping, which is crucial for safety while traversing snowy terrains.
  • Height and Cuff Design: Tall boots that extend above the ankle or even up to the calf offer better protection against snow ingress. A snug cuff or adjustable closure helps seal out snow and cold air, enhancing overall warmth and comfort.
  • Weight: Lightweight construction is important to prevent fatigue during extended wear. While insulation and waterproofing are critical, a lighter boot allows for easier movement without compromising on performance.
  • Comfort and Fit: A comfortable fit is key for long periods of wear; look for boots with ample toe space and cushioning. Additionally, features like removable liners can enhance comfort and allow for drying after a day in the snow.

How Important is Insulation in Arctic Snow Boots?

Insulation is crucial in Arctic snow boots to ensure warmth and comfort in extreme cold conditions.

  • Material Types: Various materials are used for insulation, including synthetic fibers, down, and wool. Synthetic fibers are often favored for their water resistance and ability to maintain warmth even when wet, while down provides excellent warmth-to-weight ratio but can lose insulating properties when damp. Wool is naturally moisture-wicking and helps regulate temperature, making it a popular choice for cold climates.
  • Thickness of Insulation: The thickness of the insulation directly correlates to the boot’s warmth retention capabilities. Thicker insulation typically offers better protection against extreme cold, but it can also add bulk and weight, which may affect mobility. The ideal thickness balances warmth with comfort, allowing for adequate toe movement without sacrificing heat retention.
  • Insulation Rating: Insulation in snow boots is often rated by temperature guidelines, indicating the lowest temperature the boot can protect against. A higher insulation rating means the boot can keep your feet warm in colder temperatures, which is essential for Arctic conditions. Understanding these ratings helps consumers choose boots that match their intended use and climate conditions.
  • Moisture Management: Effective insulation must also manage moisture to prevent cold feet, as dampness can quickly lead to heat loss. Many high-quality Arctic boots feature moisture-wicking linings or waterproof outer layers that work in tandem with insulation to keep the feet dry. This is especially important in snowy environments where melting snow can lead to wet socks and boots.
  • Durability of Insulation: The durability of insulation materials affects the longevity and performance of Arctic snow boots. High-quality insulation can withstand the rigors of outdoor activities without compressing or losing effectiveness over time. Boot users should look for brands that emphasize durable insulation technology, ensuring the boots remain warm and functional through multiple seasons.

What Role Does Waterproofing Play in Snow Boot Performance?

Insulation efficiency is enhanced by waterproofing because moisture can compromise the insulating properties of materials like down or synthetic fibers. Keeping moisture out ensures that these materials can perform optimally, keeping the feet warm.

Durability and longevity are significant factors since snow boots are typically subjected to harsh conditions. Waterproof materials, such as Gore-Tex or rubber, are designed to withstand wear and tear, ensuring that the boots last for multiple seasons.

Traction and safety are enhanced in waterproof snow boots, as many brands incorporate rugged outsoles designed to grip icy and snowy surfaces effectively. This feature is critical in Arctic environments where slipping can lead to serious injuries.

Comfort and breathability are increasingly important in modern snow boots. Advanced waterproofing technologies allow for moisture vapor to escape while preventing water entry, ensuring that feet stay dry and comfortable, even during vigorous activities.

Which Brands Are Recognized for the Best Arctic Snow Boots?

The following brands are recognized for producing some of the best snow boots for Arctic conditions:

  • Sorel: Sorel is famous for its durable and stylish snow boots designed to withstand extreme cold. Their boots often feature waterproof materials, thermal insulation, and rugged outsoles that provide excellent traction on icy surfaces.
  • Columbia: Columbia offers a range of snow boots that combine advanced technologies for warmth and comfort. Many of their models include Omni-Heat reflective lining to retain body heat, making them ideal for frigid Arctic environments.
  • North Face: The North Face is well-known for its high-performance outdoor gear, and their snow boots are no exception. They utilize advanced materials and construction techniques to ensure waterproofing and insulation, suitable for harsh winter conditions.
  • Salomon: Salomon specializes in outdoor sports footwear and provides snow boots that are lightweight yet robust. Their designs often include features like Contagrip outsoles for superior grip and Quicklace systems for easy adjustments, enhancing performance in snowy terrain.
  • Kamik: Kamik produces a variety of snow boots that emphasize both affordability and functionality. Many of their models are made with eco-friendly materials and offer waterproof protection along with thermal insulation, making them a practical choice for Arctic conditions.
  • Baffin: Baffin is known for its extreme cold weather boots, suitable for temperatures far below freezing. Their boots are designed with multiple insulation layers, and some models can withstand temperatures as low as -100°F, making them ideal for Arctic adventures.
  • Muck Boot Company: Muck Boot Company focuses on providing all-weather footwear that performs well in wet and cold environments. Their snow boots are often made from flexible, waterproof neoprene and rubber, ensuring comfort and warmth in snowy conditions.

What Technologies Do Leading Brands Implement for Warmth and Durability?

Leading brands implement various technologies to ensure warmth and durability in snow boots suitable for arctic conditions.

  • Insulation Materials: Brands often use advanced insulation materials like Thinsulate or PrimaLoft, which trap heat while remaining lightweight. These materials provide excellent thermal efficiency, allowing the boots to keep feet warm even in extremely cold temperatures.
  • Waterproofing Technologies: Technologies such as Gore-Tex and proprietary waterproof membranes are commonly used to keep feet dry. These materials prevent water from entering the boot while allowing moisture from perspiration to escape, ensuring comfort during prolonged wear in wet conditions.
  • Durable Outsoles: High-quality rubber outsoles designed with deep treads provide superior grip and traction on icy surfaces. Many brands incorporate compounds that remain flexible in low temperatures, enhancing durability and performance on slippery terrains.
  • Seam Sealing: Advanced seam sealing techniques are implemented to reinforce waterproofing and prevent cold air and moisture from penetrating the boots. This ensures that the integrity of the boot is maintained even under harsh weather conditions.
  • Thermal Barriers: Some snow boots feature thermal barriers or heat-reflective linings that help retain warmth. These barriers reflect body heat back into the boot, enhancing insulation and keeping feet warm during extended outdoor activities.
  • Lightweight Construction: Many leading brands focus on lightweight designs that do not compromise on insulation and durability. This allows for ease of movement and less fatigue during long treks in snowy environments.
  • Custom Fit Systems: Technologies that allow for a customizable fit, such as adjustable lacing systems or internal booties, ensure that the boot conforms to the foot’s shape. This not only enhances comfort but also minimizes heat loss and improves overall insulation performance.

How Do Brand Reputations Impact Your Choice of Arctic Boots?

Brand reputations play a significant role in the selection of the best snow boots for Arctic conditions due to consumer trust, quality assurance, and performance expectations.

  • Trust and Reliability: A brand with a solid reputation often signifies reliability in product performance, which is crucial when choosing snow boots for extreme conditions.
  • Quality Assurance: Well-established brands usually have a history of producing high-quality products, which can assure consumers that they are making a sound investment for their winter gear.
  • Consumer Reviews and Experience: Brands with positive reputations tend to have a wealth of customer reviews and testimonials, allowing potential buyers to assess the boots’ effectiveness in real-world Arctic settings.
  • Innovation and Technology: Reputable brands often invest in research and development, leading to innovative features in their snow boots that enhance warmth, waterproofing, and traction, meeting the demands of Arctic environments.
  • Brand Loyalty and Repeat Purchases: Consumers are more likely to repurchase from brands they trust, creating a cycle of brand loyalty that reinforces the brand’s reputation over time.

Trust and reliability are paramount when selecting snow boots for Arctic conditions. A well-regarded brand assures consumers that the boots will perform well under extreme weather, providing necessary protection and comfort.

Quality assurance is another critical factor, as established brands are typically known for their durable and effective products. This historical reliability can influence a buyer’s decision, ensuring that they are investing in boots that will last through harsh winter conditions.

Furthermore, consumer reviews and experiences provide valuable insights into how boots perform in real-life situations. Brands with strong reputations often have numerous positive testimonials, helping potential buyers feel confident in their choices based on the experiences of others.

Innovation and technology also play a vital role in brand reputation. Companies recognized for their cutting-edge designs and features can offer superior snow boots that excel in insulation, waterproofing, and traction, making them preferable for Arctic climates.

Lastly, brand loyalty is an essential aspect of consumer behavior. When shoppers have a positive experience with a brand, they are more inclined to purchase from them again, further solidifying the brand’s reputation in the marketplace.

What Are the Top-Rated Snow Boots for Extreme Cold?

The best snow boots for arctic conditions are designed to provide warmth, waterproofing, and traction in extreme temperatures.

  • Sorel Caribou: A classic choice, the Sorel Caribou features a waterproof leather upper and a removable, insulated liner that keeps feet warm in very low temperatures. Its durable rubber sole offers excellent traction on icy surfaces, making it ideal for arctic conditions.
  • Columbia Bugaboot Plus IV Omni-Heat: This boot boasts advanced insulation and thermal reflective lining which enhances warmth without adding bulk. The Omni-Grip outsole provides superior traction, making it suitable for slippery terrains often found in snowy, arctic environments.
  • Baffin Impact: Known for its extreme cold rating, the Baffin Impact is engineered for temperatures as low as -40°F. It features a multi-layer inner boot system that traps heat while allowing moisture to escape, keeping feet dry and warm even in the harshest conditions.
  • Kamik NationPlus: The Kamik NationPlus offers a waterproof nylon upper combined with a rubber bottom for excellent moisture protection. This boot also features a removable thermal liner, ensuring warmth and comfort during long periods in cold weather.
  • Merrell Thermo Chill Mid Waterproof: This boot combines a waterproof membrane with insulation for a lightweight yet warm option. The Vibram outsole provides exceptional grip on icy surfaces, making it a versatile choice for both urban and wild arctic adventures.

Which Boots Are Ideal for Arctic Hiking and Outdoor Activities?

Columbia Bugaboot Plus IV Omni-Heat: Equipped with Columbia’s proprietary thermal reflective lining, these boots trap heat effectively while allowing moisture to escape. This keeps your feet warm and dry during long hikes, and the rugged outsole provides superior grip on icy trails.

Kamik Greenbay 4: These boots come with a waterproof nylon upper and are insulated with synthetic materials, providing warmth even in sub-zero temperatures. The adjustable snow collar helps keep snow out, and the lightweight design makes them easy to wear for extended periods.

Muck Boot Arctic Sport: Made from a combination of rubber and neoprene, these boots offer excellent flexibility and comfort while ensuring waterproof protection. The fleece lining adds an extra layer of warmth, making them perfect for both active excursions and leisurely walks in the snow.

Northside Brutus Boots: These boots provide a great balance of price and performance, with a durable waterproof upper and sufficient insulation for cold weather. They are designed for ease of use, with a simple lacing system and a comfortable fit, making them an excellent choice for casual Arctic exploration.

What are the Best Recommendations from Experts and Reviews?

The best snow boots for arctic conditions are designed to provide warmth, traction, and waterproofing for extreme cold environments.

  • Sorel Caribou Boots: These boots feature a waterproof leather upper and a removable inner lining made of felt for added insulation. The rubber outsole provides excellent traction on icy surfaces, making them ideal for arctic conditions.
  • Columbia Bugaboot Plus IV Omni-Heat: Known for their thermal-reflective lining, these boots trap body heat while allowing moisture to escape. They also have a waterproof construction and a rugged outsole that ensures stability and grip on snow and ice.
  • Kamik NationPlus Boots: Featuring an adjustable snow collar and a waterproof nylon upper, these boots are designed to keep feet dry and warm. The lightweight insulation and durable rubber outsole provide comfort and traction, suitable for arctic adventures.
  • North Face Chilkat III Boots: These boots utilize a waterproof, breathable membrane and a heatseeker insulation that keeps feet warm in frigid temperatures. The rubber outsole is designed for slip resistance, making them perfect for walking on snow and ice.
  • Merrell Thermo Chill Mid Waterproof Boots: Combining a waterproof membrane with insulation, these boots provide warmth while keeping feet dry. They also feature a sticky rubber outsole that offers great grip on slippery surfaces, making them versatile for arctic conditions.

How Should Arctic Snow Boots Be Maintained for Longevity?

To ensure the longevity of the best snow boots for Arctic conditions, proper maintenance is crucial.

  • Regular Cleaning: Keeping your snow boots clean is essential to prevent the buildup of salt, dirt, and grime. Use a soft brush or cloth to wipe off any debris after each use, and for deeper cleaning, use a mild soap solution and water, avoiding harsh chemicals that could damage the material.
  • Drying Properly: It’s important to dry your boots properly after exposure to moisture. Remove the insoles and let them air dry at room temperature, avoiding direct heat sources, which can warp or damage the materials.
  • Waterproofing Treatments: Applying a waterproofing spray or treatment can enhance the water resistance of your snow boots. This should be done periodically or after cleaning to maintain their protective barrier against moisture and snow.
  • Storage Practices: Store your snow boots in a cool, dry place when not in use. Avoid leaving them in damp or humid areas, as this can lead to mold and mildew growth, which can degrade the materials over time.
  • Inspecting for Damage: Regularly check your boots for any signs of wear, such as cracks, loose seams, or worn-out soles. Addressing these issues promptly can prevent further damage and prolong the life of your boots.

What Common Missteps Should Be Avoided When Selecting Arctic Snow Boots?

When selecting the best snow boots for Arctic conditions, there are several common missteps to avoid for optimal performance and safety.

  • Choosing Style Over Function: It’s easy to be swayed by fashionable designs, but boots intended for Arctic conditions must prioritize insulation, waterproofing, and grip over style. Ensure that the boots are specifically designed for extreme cold and have features like thermal linings and rugged soles.
  • Ignoring Fit and Comfort: A poor fit can lead to discomfort and even frostbite in extreme temperatures. Always try on boots with the type of socks you plan to wear, ensuring there’s enough room for movement but not so much that your foot slides around.
  • Overlooking Insulation Type: Different insulation materials have varying levels of effectiveness in cold temperatures. Materials like Thinsulate or Sorel’s proprietary insulation provide warmth without bulk, while other materials may not be as effective in extreme cold.
  • Neglecting Weight: Heavy boots may seem durable, but they can lead to fatigue during long excursions. Look for boots that offer a balance between durability and lightweight construction to ensure ease of movement.
  • Forgetting Traction Needs: The Arctic environment can be treacherous with ice and snow, so traction is crucial. Opt for boots with specialized soles designed for grip, such as Vibram or aggressive rubber treads, to prevent slips and falls.
  • Disregarding Waterproof Features: Wet feet in freezing temperatures can lead to serious issues, including frostbite. Ensure the boots are not only insulated but also waterproof, with sealed seams and water-resistant materials to keep your feet dry.
  • Not Considering Breathability: While insulation and waterproofing are important, so is breathability to prevent moisture build-up from sweat. Look for boots that offer ventilation or moisture-wicking linings to maintain comfort during physical activity.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment